Dear Bloggers,
I was recently visiting with a friend from an unnamed district that has been taken over by our all knowing state. Let’s call her Amanda. When I went to Amanda’s house, her dining room table looked much like any teacher’s dining room table on a Sunday… covered with piles of papers to grade, textbooks, teacher’s editions, red pens, post-its, stickers, and endless to-do lists. She was stressed to say the least (who wouldn’t be?). She was making piles of student work and stapling evidence of reteaching, graphing data, plotting students on pointless charts, and then going back into her lesson plans to record this progress. I watched, horrified, knowing that she had been at this for several hours, and would continue to do this well after I left. This was not the end of the marking period crunch time, this was a weekly occurrence. She is not a novice teacher either, one who doesn’t have her groove yet.
I left thinking about how some all knowing bureaucrat who may never have stepped foot in a classroom thought that this endless paperwork to hold these poor overworked teachers “accountable” was the preverbal magic wand to “fix” the broken system. All this did was leave her overworked and lacking the time and energy to really and truly “plan” new and innovative lessons.
Lesson plans may take on many forms. Many teachers keep a paper and pencil plan book, some teachers may have a shared Doc, some districts have online plan books, some districts may have gotten away from this antiquated practice and require teachers to keep updated websites. (I personally think in this age of technology and transparency that this is the way to go.) But whatever the practice, the purpose is clear. Lesson plans are a plan, a simple outline to keep a teacher on track with the district's approved curriculum, and to keep us accountable.
We are no longer the college students that spent hours upon hours on one lesson, detailing to the minute how you spend your time. Back then we were required to include detailed standards, anticipatory sets, essential questions (or whatever they were called back then), both formal and informal assessments, description of modeling, independent practice, modifications, and so on and so on... Imagine if this mini dissertation was required for every day and every lesson? There would be no time for investigation into various methods of presenting content. There would not be time to look into different technology to use. Parent contact? Ha! No time for that. Grading, tracking progress, collaboration with colleagues? That would all take a back seat to filling out pages upon pages of lesson plans.
Best practices of teaching indicate greater success when students are actively engaged in their own learning. The new buzzwords in education include; flipping your classroom, blended learning, integration of technology, differentiated learning, and gradual release of responsibility. Now, picture documenting each of these practices into daily lesson plans? Would you have time to do anything but lesson plans? Especially the poor elementary teacher that teaches reading, writing, math, spelling, science and social studies all in a single day! There are districts, that in an effort to improve student performance, will ask (force) teachers to document all of this - EVERY DAY!
How is it possible to improve teaching when less time is given to do so? Rather than adding paperwork, add professional development. Give teachers more time for self improvement. If administrators are looking to "see" this gradual release of responsibility let them come and see it in person. Please don't waist my time with endless paperwork and meaningless data sheets. The real data, the meaningful data, comes from when I interact with my students. So let me interact with them.
If my student is struggling with writing, let me conference with them, give them resources for self improvement. Let me document this my own way if you want to see proof. It may be in a folder, it may be in a conference sheet, sometimes a bunch of notes may be written in my student’s notebooks as a conversation overtime to apply strategies, or possibly kept in the comments of a Google Doc. Whatever works for that student on that given assignment is what I will do.
Unlike poor Amanda, we don't make our students write a first draft, a revision, and a final copy. (She needs this evidence for bi-weekly bulletin boards) This wastes time, paper, and makes many novice writers frustrated with school and the writing process. This is not real life either. When was the last time any adult began outlining on blank paper, drafting on yellow, using various colored pens or pencils to make revisions, and recopying the whole thing on pristine white lined paper? (You haven’t done this since school when you yourself may have dreaded the "writing process").
Isn't the point of school to prepare students for real life? This is not real life! Technology is real life! Spell check and right clicking are life skills! If you didn't know how to spell a word the first time, chances are, you won't notice the error the second... This is why the developers of typing programs created those little red lines you see scrawled across your paper. Students need to be taught to pay attention to those lines and how to fix their errors. If they are not utilizing such technologies, they will never learn how to do so.
I can show growth if you let me take advantage of the technology that's out there. Leave me more time to know where my lesson is going and guide my students through that learning process.
So unlike poor Amanda, I have technology at my fingertips. I make the time to know how to implement it in my classroom. I am lucky to have the support of my administration (at least some of my administration) to be able to do this, but it’s not like that everywhere. We are constantly told to differentiate for students, yet, teachers must conform to fit into a box… you know, the little lesson plan box that must be submitted weekly. I get that lesson plans are a part of this profession. Honestly, I’d outline my life anyway even if I wasn’t being required to do so. But why not allow teachers to use the tools available to them to do this in the way that works for their classroom and their students?
Truly yours,
Another Frustrated Teacher